The 7 Best Wedding Bakeries in New York

New York City, a hub of culinary excellence, is home to some of the finest wedding bakeries in the world. Whether you’re envisioning an elaborate multi-tiered masterpiece or a simple, elegant design, the city’s talented bakers are ready to transform your dreams into reality. In this guide, we’ll explore the 7 best wedding bakeries in New York, showcasing the artistry and passion that define each one.

When choosing a wedding bakery, several services and aspects should be considered to ensure your cake is as memorable as your special day:

Custom Cake Design: Tailored creations that reflect your unique style and theme.
Tasting Sessions: Opportunities to sample different flavors and fillings.
Delivery and Setup: Ensuring your cake arrives safely and looks perfect at the venue.
Dietary Options: Gluten-free, vegan, and other special requests accommodated.
Budget Planning: Prices can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, so it’s important to plan accordingly.
Decoration and Styling: Options for intricate sugar flowers, fondant art, and more.
Consultation Services: Professional advice on flavors, design, and logistics.

Embark on your journey to find the perfect wedding bakery in New York and let your cake be a stunning centerpiece of your celebration.

1. Magnolia Bakery
2. Spoonable Spirits
3. Make My Cake

4. Julia Fedorova Cakes
5. City Sweets & Confections
6. Nina's Cakery
7. Ron Ben-Israel Cakes

Number of companies

4989

Verified reviews

4,56

Average rating

(212)4622572

1. Magnolia Bakery

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

401 Bleecker St, 10014.0, New York

Bakery
Pie shop
Restaurant
Wedding bakery

Why we chose them

Magnolia Bakery, established in 1996 in New York City’s West Village, has become a beloved destination for classic American baked goods. Known for its iconic cupcakes, this bakery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with a touch of vintage charm. Patrons can indulge in a range of delectable treats, from freshly baked cookies and brownies to seasonal assortments and corporate gift packages. The bakery also facilitates pickup orders and nationwide shipping, ensuring their delightful creations reach customers far and wide.

In addition to being a bakery, Magnolia serves as a pie shop, restaurant, and wedding bakery, catering to various occasions and celebrations. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction extends to their catering and event services, providing custom selections for any event size. With innovative collaborations and exclusive offerings, such as their DoorDash exclusive banana pudding flavors, Magnolia Bakery continues to captivate sweet-toothed enthusiasts across the country.

(917)8465330

2. Spoonable Spirits

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

214 E 85th St #1B, 10028.0, New York

Bakery
Dessert shop
Caterer
Wedding bakery

Why we chose them

Spoonable Spirits, a unique dessert company based in NYC, has gained a reputation for its innovative and delightful creations: handcrafted Jello Shots and Pudding Shots. As featured on Good Morning America, these boozy treats are designed to elevate any event, making them a popular choice for catering and special occasions. Customers nationwide can enjoy their offerings, with an adult signature required upon delivery. Their menu includes enticing flavors such as Cookies N Rum, Espresso Martini, and Choco Caramel Whiskey, ensuring a memorable experience for those 21 and older.

Specializing in services as a Bakery, Dessert shop, Caterer, and Wedding bakery, Spoonable Spirits seamlessly combines the joy of desserts with the sophistication of cocktails. Their viral sensation, the Pudding Shot Gift Pack, allows customers to choose from a variety of flavors, making it a perfect gift or party addition. With an emphasis on quality and creativity, Spoonable Spirits continues to attract dessert enthusiasts looking for something extraordinary, offering a taste of NYC’s vibrant culinary scene.

(212)2342344

3. Make My Cake

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 3,8/5

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, 10030.0, New York

Bakery
Wedding bakery
Wholesale bakery

Why we chose them

Make My Cake stands out in Harlem, New York, as a gourmet bakery infused with Southern flair. Known for “Baking Sweet Memories, One Cake at a Time,” this bakery specializes in crafting exquisite cakes that leave a lasting impression. With a wide range of services, including bakery, wedding bakery, and wholesale bakery options, they cater to both personal and business needs, ensuring every occasion is celebrated with a touch of sweetness. Their dedication to quality and flavor makes them a beloved choice in the community.

Located in the heart of Harlem, Make My Cake offers a delightful experience through its two convenient locations. Customers are drawn to the inviting atmosphere and the promise of high-quality, delicious creations. The bakery’s commitment to community engagement and customer satisfaction is evident in their service offerings, including delivery. Whether planning a wedding or simply indulging in a sweet treat, this bakery delivers exceptional products that highlight their Southern-inspired gourmet touch.

(347)6529905

4. Julia Fedorova Cakes

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

1350 6th Ave, 10019.0, New York

Wedding bakery

Why we chose them

Julia Fedorova Cakes specializes in crafting exquisite wedding cakes adorned with botanically correct sugar flowers. Known for their artistry and attention to detail, these cakes are not only visually stunning but also delicious, as praised by satisfied clients. The company operates on a by-appointment-only basis, ensuring personalized service and attention to each client’s unique wedding vision. Each creation is a testament to the skill and creativity of the cake artist, making them a sought-after choice for couples seeking something truly special for their big day.

The website highlights the company’s focus on wedding cakes, featuring detailed options and processes for ordering. The glowing reviews, such as those from Anya Deutsch, underscore the exceptional quality and taste of these cakes. The emphasis on elegance and floral design reflects the brand’s commitment to bringing bridal dreams to life. With a reputation for excellence and a distinct artistic flair, this company is an outstanding addition to any wedding celebration, offering a unique blend of sophistication and sweetness.

(917)8171058

5. City Sweets & Confections

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

***BY APPOINTMENT ONLY, 218 Sullivan St, 10012.0, New York

Wedding bakery
Bakery

Why we chose them

City Sweets & Confections is a renowned couture cake art studio known for its exquisite and unique wedding cakes. Founded in 2000 by Deborah Lauren, this Manhattan-based bakery has become a go-to destination for couples seeking a statement piece that complements their wedding decor. Offering a wide array of designs, from bohemian to contemporary styles, they incorporate elements like succulent touches, geometric details, and hand-painted florals. Each cake is a masterpiece, combining artistic flair with culinary excellence, ensuring that it not only looks stunning but also tastes divine.

Specializing in custom-designed cakes, City Sweets & Confections boasts a selection of over 50 flavors, using premium ingredients such as Valrhona chocolate and Madagascar vanilla. Their cakes are renowned for their moist texture and rich flavors, with buttercream frosting made from real dairy products providing the perfect complement. The studio’s hand-sculpted sugar flowers, often mistaken for real blooms, add a touch of elegance to their creations. By offering personalized confections that reflect each couple’s unique vision, City Sweets & Confections has earned a reputation for delivering not just cakes, but unforgettable experiences.

(917)6034149

6. Nina's Cakery

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,9/5

401 E 34th St, 10016.0, New York

Bakery
Caterer
Wedding bakery

Why we chose them

Nina’s Cakery is a boutique bakery renowned for creating stunning and delicious cakes tailored to each client’s needs. Specializing as a bakery, caterer, and wedding bakery, they craft each cake individually to order, ensuring a personalized touch and exceptional quality. Though they do not operate a retail store, their creations are available with several days’ notice, and in some cases, same-day service is possible. This commitment to unique, handcrafted cakes sets them apart in the bustling New York City and eastern Long Island areas.

Why did we choose this company for our directory? The dedication to excellence and creativity makes them an outstanding choice for any celebration. Their recent creations can be viewed on Instagram @ninascakerynyc, showcasing the artistry and care that go into each cake. For those seeking a memorable and delicious centerpiece for their event, this bakery delivers both flavor and visual appeal, making it a standout option in the region.

(212)6253369

7. Ron Ben-Israel Cakes

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,2/5

247 West 38th Street Floor Thirteen, 10018.0, New York

Wedding bakery
Cake shop
Cookie shop
Pastry shop

Why we chose them

Ron Ben-Israel Cakes is a renowned cake design studio, celebrated for its innovative and exquisite confections. With a legacy spanning over two decades, the studio has set trends in the world of cake artistry both domestically and internationally. Founded by the visionary Ron Ben-Israel, the company has become synonymous with elegant and intricately designed cakes. Known as the “Manolo Blahnik of wedding cakes,” his creations are frequently featured in prestigious publications such as Martha Stewart Weddings and New York Magazine. The studio specializes in crafting custom-made wedding cakes, celebration cakes, and designer cakes, with each piece reflecting a unique artistic vision.

Located in New York’s Historic Garment District, the studio operates by appointment only, ensuring each client receives personalized attention. Ron’s passion for the art and science of baking is evident in every cake, where he and his team approach each project with the excitement of an opening night performance. The company also excels in sharing its expertise through teaching, offering workshops and master classes worldwide. As a committed member of the Food Council of City Harvest, Ron actively participates in charitable activities, reflecting his dedication to giving back to the community. His journey from aspiring fine artist to America’s cake maestro highlights his commitment to excellence and innovation in the confectionery arts.

FAQs

What services do wedding bakeries in New York typically offer?

Wedding bakeries in New York usually offer custom cake design, tasting sessions, delivery and setup, dietary options, budget planning, decoration and styling, and consultation services.

How much should I expect to spend on a wedding cake in New York?

The average price range for a wedding cake in New York is between €450 and €2,500, depending on the complexity of the design and the size of the cake.

How far in advance should I book a wedding bakery?

It's recommended to book your wedding bakery at least 6 to 12 months in advance, especially if you have a specific date in mind or are considering a popular bakery.

What should I consider when choosing a wedding bakery?

Consider the bakery's style and portfolio, tasting session availability, customer reviews, budget alignment, dietary options offered, and how they handle delivery and setup.

Can wedding bakeries accommodate special dietary requirements?

Yes, many wedding bakeries offer gluten-free, vegan, and other dietary options to ensure all guests can enjoy the cake.

What is the process of designing a custom wedding cake?

The process typically involves an initial consultation to discuss your vision, a tasting session to select flavors, and collaborative design meetings to finalize the cake's look and details.

Do wedding bakeries provide delivery and setup services?

Yes, most wedding bakeries offer delivery and setup services to ensure that your cake arrives safely and is perfectly presented at your venue.

Are tasting sessions included in the cost of the wedding cake?

Tasting sessions are often included in the overall cost, but some bakeries may charge a small fee, which could be deducted from the final price if you decide to book with them.