The 7 Best Vintage Clothing Stores in New York

New York City is a treasure trove for fashion enthusiasts, especially those with a passion for vintage clothing. In a city where history and style intertwine, discovering unique pieces from bygone eras is an adventure. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a curious newcomer, our guide to the 7 Best Vintage Clothing Stores in New York will lead you to the finest spots for finding timeless fashion gems.

Shopping for vintage clothing offers more than just the thrill of the hunt. These stores often provide a range of services and experiences that can enhance your visit. Here are some of the offerings and aspects to consider:

Personal Styling: Expert advice to help you find the perfect ensemble that reflects your unique taste.
Alteration Services: Tailoring options to ensure the perfect fit for your vintage finds.
Authenticity Verification: Assurance that the pieces are genuine and from the era they claim to be.
Rental Options: Opportunities to rent one-of-a-kind pieces for special occasions.
Price Range: A spectrum of prices, from budget-friendly steals to high-end collectibles, typically ranging from $20 to several hundred dollars.
Curated Collections: Carefully selected pieces that showcase the best of different decades.
Sustainable Shopping: An eco-friendly way to shop by giving pre-loved clothing a new life.

Prepare to dive into the world of vintage fashion and explore the unique offerings of New York’s vibrant vintage scene in our comprehensive guide.

1. Buffalo Exchange
2. Metropolis Vintage
3. Screaming Mimis Vintage

4. Church Street Surplus
5. Lara Koleji
6. November 19 Shop
7. The Re:Shop

Number of companies

1233

Verified reviews

4,24

Average rating

(212)6753535

1. Buffalo Exchange

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 3,6/5

114 W 26th St, 10001.0, New York

Vintage clothing store
Consignment shop
Costume store
Thrift store
Clothing store

Why we chose them

Buffalo Exchange stands out as a dynamic hub for fashion enthusiasts in Chelsea, New York, offering a unique blend of services including a vintage clothing store, consignment shop, costume store, thrift store, and clothing store. Known for its hip, used apparel, the company provides an engaging shopping experience for those seeking unique fashion finds. Customers can sell their clothing and accessories without an appointment, thanks to an innovative system that allows sellers to scan a QR code upon arrival and receive a notification when it’s their turn. This seamless process ensures that fashion-forward individuals can easily contribute to and benefit from the store’s diverse collection.

Located conveniently near major subway lines, the store is accessible for locals and visitors alike. With extended hours from Monday to Saturday, and slightly shorter hours on Sundays, customers have ample time to explore the eclectic selection of apparel. The company also embraces community spirit through initiatives like “50 Acts of Kindness,” making it not just a shopping destination but a community partner. By signing up for their updates, fashion lovers can stay informed about exclusive sales and new items that the store is buying, ensuring that they never miss out on the latest trends and deals.

(212)3580795

2. Metropolis Vintage

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 3,8/5

803 Broadway, 10003.0, New York

Vintage clothing store

Why we chose them

Metropolis Vintage is a standout thrift shop in NYC, renowned for its specialization in vintage footwear and eclectic apparel spanning the 1970s to the 2000s. With an impressive collection that includes music t-shirts, pants, overalls, leather jackets, and sports apparel, this store has something for everyone. Their dedication to offering a diverse range of styles and fashions makes them a must-visit for vintage enthusiasts and fashion seekers alike. With two floors filled with carefully curated items, customers are guaranteed to find unique pieces that reflect their personal style.

What sets this vintage clothing store apart is their frequent stock updates, ensuring there’s always a fresh selection of treasures to discover. From winter apparel to workwear, the variety is vast and ever-changing, catering to all tastes and preferences. The commitment to offering quality vintage clothing and accessories positions them as the best vintage clothing store in NYC, making them a valuable addition to our directory of distinguished businesses.

(212)6776464

3. Screaming Mimis Vintage

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

240 W 14th St, 10011.0, New York

Vintage clothing store
Costume store

Why we chose them

Screaming Mimis Vintage stands out as a premier destination for fashion enthusiasts seeking high-end vintage clothing and unique costume pieces. Known for its carefully curated collection, the store offers an eclectic range of items from iconic eras, featuring labels like Yves Saint Laurent and Helmut Lang. This vintage haven caters to those with a keen eye for style, offering everything from dresses and outerwear to specialized accessories and menswear. Their expertly selected pieces ensure that every item tells a story, making it a must-visit for both fashion collectors and those seeking standout wardrobe additions.

Located in the heart of NYC, the store enhances its shopping experience with an inviting atmosphere and a dedicated team ready to assist in finding the perfect piece. Customers can also explore their offerings online, where new arrivals frequently update the extensive selection. With a strong presence on social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, the store stays connected with its community, sharing the latest trends and exclusive items. Whether in-store or online, Screaming Mimis Vintage provides a unique shopping experience, blending classic elegance with contemporary flair.

(212)2265280

4. Church Street Surplus

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,1/5

327 Church St, 10013.0, New York

Vintage clothing store
Army & navy surplus shop

Why we chose them

Church Street Surplus stands out as a unique destination in New York City, specializing in vintage and military collectible clothing. Since 1972, this store has captivated fashion enthusiasts with its extensive collection of U.S. Army/Navy and European camouflage apparel, alongside original 1960s-1980s leather, denim, and suede jackets. Known for its curated assortment of vintage, US-made, 100% cotton high-waisted jeans and dresses, the shop also offers a remarkable selection of antique quilts, chenilles, and textiles. This makes it a favored spot for costume designers, stylists, and fashion designers seeking authentic pieces for creative projects.

The store’s reputation is further enhanced by its collaborations with popular shows such as “Boardwalk Empire,” “The Blacklist,” and “SNL,” showcasing its influence in the entertainment industry. With features in notable publications like Vogue, Grazia, and Cool Hunting, the brand’s impact extends beyond fashion circles. Ranked #15 in Ethical Bliss, Church Street Surplus has gained recognition for its ethical approach and unique offerings, making it a valuable addition to our company directory for anyone seeking timeless and distinct fashion items.

(646)9280083

5. Lara Koleji

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

70 Orchard St, 10002.0, New York

Vintage clothing store

Why we chose them

Discover the charm of vintage fashion with Lara Koleji, a standout in the world of retro style. Known for its carefully curated selection, this vintage clothing store offers a unique shopping experience that transports customers to the elegance of bygone eras. The store’s commitment to quality and authenticity is evident in its collection, which includes timeless pieces that appeal to fashion enthusiasts and collectors alike.

Chosen for our directory due to its distinctive appeal, the store stands out on platforms like Instagram, where it showcases its exquisite range of vintage apparel. With a focus on sustainability and style, it caters to those who appreciate the artistry of fashion history while seeking to make environmentally conscious choices. This dedication to preserving and celebrating vintage fashion makes it an essential addition to our curated list of unique and noteworthy establishments.

(646)8388386

6. November 19 Shop

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,8/5

37 Orchard St, 10002.0, New York

Vintage clothing store
Clothing store
Gift shop
Stationery store
Home goods store

Why we chose them

November 19 Shop stands out as a unique destination for those seeking a blend of vintage clothing, home goods, and lifestyle products. Specializing in a curated selection of items, this store caters to diverse tastes with offerings that include clothing, gifts, stationery, and home decor. The shop is known for its eclectic range, featuring everything from handmade artist pieces to fashion finds. A notable highlight is their commitment to prompt service, with online orders shipped within 1-2 business days, ensuring a seamless shopping experience.

The store’s carefully chosen inventory includes popular brands like Moismont and Cosi Tabellini, offering items such as wool scarves, enamelware, and elegant glassware. Customers can explore categories ranging from tabletop essentials to personal accessories, making it a versatile shopping hub. The shop also connects with its audience via social media platforms like Instagram and Pinterest, keeping them updated on the latest arrivals and trends. The combination of vintage charm and modern convenience makes this shop a valuable addition to our directory.

7. The Re:Shop

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

423 Broadway, 10013.0, New York

Vintage clothing store

Why we chose them

The ReShop is a vibrant vintage clothing store that champions sustainability and style. With a focus on reusing the world’s natural resources, the store offers a diverse selection of unique, pre-loved items, ranging from ’80s U.S. Military Camo Combat Cargo Uniform Trouser Pants to classic Levi 501 Jeans. Each piece is carefully curated to provide customers with distinctive fashion choices that celebrate the charm of bygone eras. The company’s commitment to improving quality of life on Earth is evident in its efforts to save unwanted clothing from landfills, making it a standout choice for eco-conscious consumers.

In addition to its impressive collection of vintage attire, the store is known for its featured collections like The Classic Flannel Collection and The Sweater Edition. The Reclaimed Denim Collection is a particular highlight, showcasing reworked and reimagined styles. With new arrivals constantly updating their inventory, the store is a treasure trove for fashion enthusiasts seeking one-of-a-kind pieces. Located in the heart of Soho NYC, the store’s ethos, “Be cool, wear used,” resonates with those looking to make a stylish statement while supporting sustainable practices.

FAQs

What types of services do vintage clothing stores in New York typically offer?

Vintage clothing stores often provide personal styling, alteration services, authenticity verification, rental options, and curated collections to enhance your shopping experience.

How much do vintage clothing items typically cost in New York?

Prices for vintage clothing in New York can vary widely, ranging from budget-friendly options at around €18 to high-end collectibles costing several hundred euros.

Can I get clothing altered at a vintage store, and how much does it usually cost?

Yes, many vintage stores offer alteration services to ensure a perfect fit. The cost for alterations can range from €25 to €100, depending on the complexity of the work.

What should I look for when choosing a vintage clothing store?

Consider factors such as the range of styles, authenticity of pieces, availability of services like styling and alterations, and customer reviews to find a store that suits your needs.

How do I verify the authenticity of vintage clothing items?

Many stores provide authenticity verification services. Look for stores with knowledgeable staff who can provide information on the era, brand, and condition of the item.

Are there rental options available for vintage clothing in New York?

Yes, several vintage stores offer rental options for unique pieces, perfect for special occasions. Rental prices typically range from €30 to €150, depending on the item.

What is the typical timeline for purchasing and altering a vintage piece?

The timeline can vary, but generally, purchasing and altering a vintage piece can take anywhere from a few days to a couple of weeks, depending on the availability of services.

How can shopping for vintage clothing be a sustainable choice?

Vintage shopping is eco-friendly as it gives pre-loved clothing a new life, reducing waste and the demand for new manufacturing, which can be resource-intensive.