The 7 Best Pizza Takeouts in New York

New York City is synonymous with many things, but perhaps nothing is more iconic than its pizza. With countless options available, finding the best pizza takeout can be both thrilling and overwhelming. That’s why we’ve curated a list of the 7 Best Pizza Takeouts in New York, highlighting the very best this culinary capital has to offer. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this guide will help you navigate through the city’s rich pizza landscape with ease.

When considering a pizza takeout in New York, here are some aspects and services to keep in mind:

Variety of Toppings: From classic pepperoni to gourmet options like truffle oil and prosciutto.
Crust Styles: Thin, thick, gluten-free, or stuffed crusts to cater to every preference.
Price Range: Options to suit every budget, from $10 slices to $30 gourmet pies.
Delivery Speed: Fast and reliable delivery, perfect for those spontaneous pizza cravings.
Quality Ingredients: Fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that enhance flavor and authenticity.
Customizable Orders: Build-your-own pizza options for a personalized experience.
Special Deals: Discounts and offers that make indulging in pizza even more tempting.

With these considerations in mind, dive into the main content to discover the 7 best pizza takeouts, each offering a unique taste of New York.

1. Joe's Pizza Broadway
2. Joe's Pizza
3. Lombardi's Pizza

4. Bleecker Street Pizza
5. Joe’s Pizza
6. $1.50 Fresh Pizza
7. Uncle Paul's Pizza NY

Number of companies

53697

Verified reviews

4,44

Average rating

(646)5594878

1. Joe's Pizza Broadway

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

1435 Broadway, 10018.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Pizza delivery
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Joe’s Pizza Broadway is a staple in the heart of New York City, known for its classic NYC slice shop experience. This iconic establishment has earned its spot in our directory for its unwavering commitment to delivering authentic and delicious pizza. Whether you’re dining in or opting for their convenient pizza delivery service, each slice promises the perfect balance of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese, embodying the quintessential New York pizza experience.

Offering a welcoming atmosphere, this pizza restaurant is a go-to spot for both locals and tourists seeking a genuine taste of the city. The simplicity and tradition of their menu highlight their dedication to quality, making it a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts. By featuring Joe’s Pizza Broadway, we celebrate a beloved institution that continues to define what it means to enjoy a classic New York slice.

(212)3661182

2. Joe's Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

7 Carmine St, 10014.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Fast food restaurant
Pizza Takeout
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Joe’s Pizza, a classic New York-style pizzeria, has been a beloved institution in Greenwich Village since 1975. Established by Joe Pozzuoli, originally from Naples, Italy, it offers an authentic slice of New York history. Known for its iconic street slices, the pizzeria is a favorite among both locals and tourists. Over the years, Joe’s dedication to quality and tradition has cemented its reputation as a must-visit destination for anyone craving the quintessential New York pizza experience.

Offering a variety of services, including a pizza restaurant, fast food restaurant, and pizza takeout, Joe’s ensures that every customer can enjoy their famous slices in the way that suits them best. Despite its growth and popularity, the pizzeria remains under the watchful eye of its founder, Joe Pozzuoli, who continues to operate the restaurant at the age of 75. This long-standing commitment to quality and tradition is why Joe’s Pizza stands out as a noteworthy addition to our directory.

(212)9417994

3. Lombardi's Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,1/5

32 Spring St, 10012.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza Takeout

Why we chose them

Lombardi’s Pizza is celebrated as America’s first pizzeria, having been established in 1905 in the Little Italy section of Manhattan. Known for crafting the original New York Style pizza, it continues to draw both locals and visitors with its signature coal oven-baked pies. These pizzas feature a beautifully smoky crust topped with purist tomato sauce, fresh whole milk mozzarella, and basil, offering an authentic taste that has stood the test of time. The establishment’s rich heritage and dedication to quality make it a cornerstone of New York City’s culinary history.

This classic pizza joint offers pizza restaurant, pizza delivery, and pizza takeout services, ensuring that its iconic flavors can be enjoyed both on-site and at home. Customers can also order through Gold Belly, allowing them to savor the renowned Lombardi’s experience from virtually anywhere. The pizzeria’s commitment to maintaining its traditional methods, while offering modern conveniences, highlights its enduring appeal and relevance in today’s fast-paced world.

(212)9244466

4. Bleecker Street Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

69 7th Ave S, 10014.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Fast food restaurant
Italian restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza Takeout
Restaurant
Sicilian restaurant

Why we chose them

Bleecker Street Pizza has earned its reputation as a New York icon, celebrated for its award-winning pizzas and authentic Italian flavors. Nestled in the vibrant heart of the city, this establishment is renowned for its signature Nona Marie Pie, an old family recipe that has captivated locals and visitors alike. Voted “Best Pizza in New York” by Food Network for three consecutive years, and highly praised by Trip Advisor, USA Today, and the NY Times, this no-frills pizzeria offers a genuine taste of Italy. With a diverse menu featuring fresh ingredients and options like gluten-free pizzas, it caters to all tastes, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience for everyone.

As a multifaceted dining destination, the pizzeria serves as a pizza restaurant, fast food restaurant, Italian restaurant, and lunch restaurant, offering both dine-in and convenient delivery and takeout services. Their focus on high-quality ingredients is evident in each bite, with offerings like mozzarella, marinara sauce, and basil creating a symphony of flavors. The inviting atmosphere, combined with speedy service, makes it a go-to spot for pizza lovers in the Upper Manhattan area and beyond. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or a unique pie, this pizzeria is dedicated to satisfying your cravings with every order.

(212)2670860

5. Joe’s Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

124 Fulton St, 10038.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Pizza Takeout

Why we chose them

Joe’s Pizza, a legendary NYC-style counter slice shop, has been a cornerstone of Greenwich Village since its establishment in 1975 by Joe Pozzuoli, who hails from Naples, Italy—the birthplace of pizza. This iconic eatery has earned its reputation as a “Greenwich Village institution,” serving an authentic New York street slice for over 47 years. Nestled at 7 Carmine Street, it continues to attract both native New Yorkers and tourists, making it a beloved spot for anyone craving a classic slice of New York’s culinary tradition.

Renowned for its commitment to authenticity, the restaurant proudly offers both Pizza Restaurant and Pizza Takeout services. Under the vigilant ownership of 75-year-old Joe Pozzuoli, the establishment maintains its charm and quality, ensuring every slice embodies the essence of New York pizza. This dedication to excellence and tradition makes it a standout choice for our directory, showcasing the best of NYC’s vibrant food scene.

(212)2452155

6. $1.50 Fresh Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

1723 Broadway, 10019.0, New York

Pizza Takeout
Fast food restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza restaurant

Why we chose them

$1.50 Fresh Pizza has been a staple in the NYC pizza scene since 2001, offering hot and fresh slices that have become a favorite for locals and visitors alike. Known for its humble counter-serve approach, this fast food restaurant caters to those seeking quick and delicious pizza takeout and delivery. With six highly rated locations throughout New York City, the company ensures that its specialties are always ready for pickup or delivery through popular platforms like DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub, and more. The convenience and quality of their service make them a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts.

This pizza restaurant not only excels in providing classic NYC pizza slices but also offers a variety of options to suit different tastes. Open late into the night, they accommodate the city’s bustling lifestyle by serving customers from morning until the early hours. The strategic locations around the city make it easy for anyone to enjoy their tasty offerings, whether you’re walking in or ordering online. Their commitment to quality and accessibility makes them a noteworthy addition to our company directory.

(212)9221200

7. Uncle Paul's Pizza NY

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

70 Vanderbilt Ave, 10017.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Wine bar

Why we chose them

Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY is a vibrant, casual 24-hour Italian eatery known for its diverse menu and welcoming atmosphere. Offering a range of services including pizza dining, delivery, and a wine bar, this establishment caters to a variety of culinary preferences. With a menu featuring classic options like Neapolitan Cheese Pizza and more inventive selections such as Lasagna Pizza, Uncle Paul’s satisfies both traditional and adventurous palates. The addition of appetizers, salads, calzones, and an array of pasta dishes ensures a comprehensive Italian dining experience for every customer.

This pizza haven is particularly celebrated for its specialty pies and authentic Italian fare. From the rich flavors of Grandma Pizza to the savory delights of Chicken Parmigiana, every dish is crafted with quality ingredients. The wine bar complements the menu, offering patrons a relaxed setting to enjoy their meals. Whether dining in or opting for pizza delivery, guests can enjoy the convenience and taste that make this eatery a standout choice in New York’s bustling culinary scene.

FAQs

What are the most popular types of crusts available for pizza takeout in New York?

In New York, you can find a variety of crust styles for pizza takeout, including thin crust, thick crust, gluten-free options, and stuffed crusts. Each style caters to different taste preferences.

What is the average price range for pizza takeout in New York?

The price for pizza takeout in New York can range from approximately €9 for a single slice to €28 for a gourmet pie, depending on the size and ingredients.

How fast can I expect my pizza delivery in New York?

Delivery times can vary, but most pizza takeouts in New York offer fast and reliable delivery, often within 30 to 45 minutes, depending on your location and the time of day.

What should I consider when choosing a pizza takeout service in New York?

Consider factors such as the variety of toppings, crust options, price range, delivery speed, quality of ingredients, and any special deals or discounts available.

Are there customizable pizza options available for takeout in New York?

Yes, many pizza takeout places in New York offer customizable options, allowing you to build-your-own pizza with a wide range of toppings and crust choices.

How can I ensure the quality of ingredients in my pizza takeout?

Look for takeout services that emphasize fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and have positive customer reviews regarding the taste and quality of their pizzas.

Are there any special deals or discounts available for pizza takeout in New York?

Many pizza takeout services in New York offer special deals and discounts, especially during weekdays or for larger orders. It's worth checking their websites or asking directly.

How do I find the best pizza takeout in New York?

Research online reviews, ask for recommendations from locals, and consider factors like menu variety, pricing, and delivery options to find the best pizza takeout that suits your taste and budget.