Top 7 Best Pet Sitters in New York

Finding the perfect pet sitter in New York City can be a daunting task, but it’s crucial for ensuring your furry friends are well cared for while you’re away. Our guide to the ‘Top 7 Best Pet Sitters in New York’ aims to simplify your search by highlighting the most reliable and professional options available in the city.

When choosing a pet sitter, consider the range of services they offer to meet your specific needs:

Daily dog walking
Overnight care in your home
Pet grooming services
Administration of medications
Specialized care for senior pets
Feeding and watering routines
Pet transportation services
Emergency care options

Additionally, consider these important aspects when selecting a pet sitter:

Experience with specific breeds or types of pets
Availability and flexibility in scheduling
Reputation and customer reviews
Cost and value, typically ranging from $15 to $50 per visit
Insurance and bonding for peace of mind

Explore our detailed guide to find the ideal pet sitter that caters to your pet’s needs, ensuring a stress-free experience for both you and your beloved companion.

1. Wags West
2. New York Tails
3. The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties LLC

4. Bare Paws NYC Dog Walkers & Pet Sitters
5. Elena's Pets
6. Play Pals NYC
7. BarkBud Dog Walkers

Number of companies

367

Verified reviews

4,94

Average rating

(917)8171073

1. Wags West

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,9/5

157 Columbus Ave 4th floor, 10023.0, New York

Pet sitter
Dog walker

Why we chose them

Wags West has been a beloved fixture in the Upper West Side since its founding in 2010. Locally-based and family-owned, the company was inspired by the founders’ passion for pets, sparked by their own experience with their Australian Cattle Dog mix, Boudreaux. The team is composed of experienced and well-trained professionals who are dedicated to providing top-notch dog walking and cat sitting services. They cater to neighborhoods such as Lincoln Center, Waterline Square, Riverside Blvd, and Morningside Heights, ensuring the pets in these communities receive the personal attention they deserve.

Clients of this pet care service can rely on tailored care plans for their animals, from specialized puppy visits to fulfilling cat visits that ease the minds of pet owners. Known for their commitment to pet well-being, they emphasize the importance of exercise and attention, promising that a “tired dog is a happy dog.” This dedication is reflected in the glowing reviews from satisfied pet parents, who praise the company’s outstanding and loving service. Their position as a trusted choice for pet owners in the Upper West Side is a testament to their passion and expertise in pet care.

(212)7069560

2. New York Tails

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

318 E 80th St, 10075.0, New York

Dog walker
Pet sitter

Why we chose them

New York Tails stands out as a premier pet care provider in New York City, offering a diverse range of services including dog walking, pet sitting, day care, and dog boarding. Their dedicated team, led by Kira and Paulo, ensures that each pet receives personalized attention and care, making every experience enjoyable and fulfilling. With a focus on safety and comfort, they provide a family-oriented atmosphere where pets can thrive. The company’s commitment to flexibility accommodates the hectic lifestyles of city dwellers, offering customizable options to suit the unique needs of their clients and their furry companions.

Emphasizing transparency and communication, New York Tails maintains constant updates between pet owners and walkers, ensuring peace of mind. Their highly trained staff guarantees attentive care, never walking more than four dogs at a time for optimal supervision. The user-friendly online booking system and comprehensive office support streamline the process, making it easy for clients to schedule and manage services. With a strong reputation backed by glowing reviews, New York Tails is a trusted choice for pet owners seeking top-tier care for their beloved animals.

(646)4207676

3. The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties LLC

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

222 W 14th St, 10011.0, New York

Pet sitter

Why we chose them

The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties LLC offers a unique and personalized pet sitter experience for cat owners in NYC. Unlike typical referral agencies, the company ensures seamless care by having its independent contractors familiar with one another, allowing for smooth transitions and communication if a backup sitter is needed. Clients are assured that no one will enter their homes without explicit authorization. The owner, Sylvie Gilbert-Pellegrin, personally meets with all new clients and oversees the introduction between sitters and cat owners, ensuring a perfect match and a high standard of service. Her thorough vetting process, which includes background checks and reference verifications, has established the company’s reputation for reliability and excellence in cat care.

The company emphasizes the emotional needs of cats, challenging common misconceptions about their independence. Cats require daily interaction and attention, and the sitters referred by the company are described as “amazing and outstanding cat whisperers.” Whether owners are away on a trip or simply at work, the company’s sitters provide companionship and playtime, ensuring that feline companions feel loved and cared for. This focus on the well-being of the cats, combined with a trusted referral system, makes the service a standout choice for cat owners seeking quality care.

(646)4361687

4. Bare Paws NYC Dog Walkers & Pet Sitters

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

157 East 86th St 5th floor, 10028.0, New York

Dog walker

Why we chose them

Bare Paws NYC Dog Walkers & Pet Sitters has established itself as a trusted provider of pet care services since 2016, catering to over 300 pets across four NYC boroughs. Known for their personal and professional approach, they offer a variety of services including dog walking, pet sitting, and cat sitting. They provide flexible options such as semi-private and private dog walks, ensuring that every pet receives the attention and care they deserve. Their innovative use of GPS technology and photo updates keeps pet owners informed and reassured, making them a standout choice in the bustling city.

The company operates in diverse neighborhoods, from the Upper East Side to Williamsburg, reflecting their extensive reach and dedication to serving NYC’s pet community. They offer hassle-free scheduling through an online portal, allowing clients to easily book services as needed. With a commitment to consistency, pets are matched with the same caregiver for each visit, facilitating a comforting and reliable experience. Their policies, including flexible cancellations and no minimum visit requirements, highlight their understanding of the unpredictable nature of city life, making them an ideal choice for pet owners seeking reliable and compassionate care.

(347)3495660

5. Elena's Pets

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

600 W 149th St, 10031.0, New York

Pet sitter

Why we chose them

Elena’s Pets stands out as a dedicated and trustworthy pet care service located in the vibrant neighborhoods of Upper Manhattan, particularly Hamilton Heights and surrounding areas. Since its establishment in the summer of 2018, the company has been committed to providing full-time care and love to every fur baby in their care. With a personalized approach, they ensure that pets are treated as if they were their own, offering peace of mind to pet owners. The company is fully insured and registered with New York State, emphasizing professionalism and reliability in all aspects of their operations.

The team at this pet care service consists of highly experienced independent contractors like Taj, Julia, and Kika, each bringing their unique expertise and passion for animals. Taj is known for his professional and responsible care, with pets often taking to him immediately. Julia, a “Star Sitter” on the Rover platform, is praised for her gentle and timely service. Kika, with nearly two decades in Harlem, has a deep connection with the local community and is a strong advocate for sheltered animals. With various flexible payment plans and a clear cancellation policy, the company ensures convenience and transparency for its clients.

(443)4136973

6. Play Pals NYC

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

67 8th Ave, 10014.0, New York

Pet sitter
Dog walker

Why we chose them

Play Pals NYC stands out in the bustling cityscape of Manhattan and Williamsburg, Brooklyn, by offering exceptional Dog Walking and Cat Sitting services. Their commitment to providing loving, professional, and fun pet care ensures that pets receive the best experience, whether owners are at work or on vacation. Play Pals NYC’s signature GPS-tracked walks cater to dogs of all breeds and sizes, offering mental, physical, and social stimulation. This personalized approach keeps pets happy and engaged, making it an ideal choice for pet owners seeking reliable and attentive care.

The company’s dedication to pet care is further highlighted by their comprehensive Cat Sitting service. Each session includes affection, playtime, and physical stimulation, ensuring cats are well-cared-for in their owner’s absence. Services include feeding, fresh water supply, litter changes, and optional grooming. With a focus on ensuring a positive experience for every pet, Play Pals NYC has earned its place in our directory as a trusted provider of pet care services, delivered with a genuine smile and a passion for animal well-being.

(646)3896256

7. BarkBud Dog Walkers

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 5,0/5

610 5th Ave, 10020.0, New York

Pet sitter
Dog walker

Why we chose them

BarkBud Dog Walkers stands out in Midtown East for its exceptional dog walking and pet sitting services. With over 400,000 dog walks completed, their expertise is unmatched. The company offers private, one-on-one dog walks, ensuring personalized attention for each pet, and utilizes a proprietary GPS app to provide real-time tracking. Pet owners receive text notifications at the start and end of each walk, along with photos and route maps. The team is composed of locally vetted, professional dog walkers who are background checked, insured, and bonded, ensuring peace of mind for pet owners.

In addition to dog walking, BarkBud offers complimentary feeding and medication services, catering to all dietary and medical needs. The company boasts flexible scheduling, accommodating walks from 6 AM to 11 PM without extra charges for holidays or weekends. They guarantee appointments with just five business hours’ notice, ensuring reliable service even if a regular walker is unavailable. Their commitment to quality is reflected in numerous five-star reviews on Yelp, making them a top choice for pet owners in the area.

FAQs

What services do pet sitters in New York typically offer?

Pet sitters in New York often provide a range of services including daily dog walking, overnight care in your home, pet grooming, administration of medications, specialized care for senior pets, feeding and watering routines, pet transportation, and emergency care options.

How much does a pet sitter in New York usually charge?

The cost for pet sitting services in New York typically ranges from €14 to €47 per visit, depending on the specific services required and the sitter's experience.

How can I choose the right pet sitter for my needs?

To choose the right pet sitter, consider their experience with specific breeds or types of pets, availability, flexibility in scheduling, reputation, customer reviews, cost, and whether they are insured and bonded.

Are pet sitters available for last-minute bookings in New York?

Many pet sitters in New York offer flexibility and can accommodate last-minute bookings, but it's advisable to contact them directly to confirm their availability.

Do pet sitters offer specialized care for senior pets?

Yes, many pet sitters provide specialized care tailored to the needs of senior pets, including medication administration and adjusted exercise routines.

Is insurance and bonding important when selecting a pet sitter?

Yes, choosing a pet sitter who is insured and bonded offers peace of mind, as it provides coverage for any accidents or incidents that may occur during the care of your pet.

Can pet sitters help with pet grooming?

Many pet sitters offer grooming services, either as part of their package or as an additional option. It's best to inquire about specific grooming services when contacting a sitter.

What should I expect during an initial meeting with a potential pet sitter?

During an initial meeting, you should discuss your pet's specific needs, routines, and any special requirements. It's also a good opportunity to assess the sitter's compatibility with your pet and ask about their experience and services.