The 7 Best Ice Cream Shops in New York

New York City, a bustling metropolis known for its diverse culinary scene, offers a delectable array of options for dessert lovers. Among these, the city’s ice cream shops stand out as must-visit destinations, providing both locals and tourists with a sweet escape from the urban hustle. In this guide, we’ll explore the 7 best ice cream shops in New York, each offering its unique twist on this timeless treat.

When choosing the perfect spot for your next ice cream indulgence, consider the following services and aspects that enhance the experience:

Variety of Flavors: From classic vanilla to exotic seasonal specials, a wide range of flavors can elevate your ice cream adventure.
Homemade Options: Many shops offer homemade ice creams, ensuring freshness and unique taste profiles.
Vegan and Dairy-Free Options: A selection of plant-based alternatives caters to dietary preferences and restrictions.
Innovative Toppings: Creative toppings like caramel drizzle, fresh fruits, and gourmet sprinkles add an extra layer of delight.
Customizable Sundaes: Build-your-own sundae options allow for a personalized dessert experience.
Affordability: Prices can vary, typically ranging from $3 to $10 per serving, ensuring something for every budget.
Ambiance: The shop’s atmosphere, whether it’s quirky, cozy, or modern, can enhance the overall enjoyment.
Location: Accessibility and proximity to popular attractions might influence your choice.

Join us as we delve into the sweet world of New York City’s top ice cream destinations, each offering a unique blend of flavors, creativity, and charm.

1. Venchi Chocolate & Gelato
2. Morgenstern's Bananas
3. Anita La Mamma del Gelato

4. FIGO il Gelato Italiano
5. Ray's Candy Store
6. Venchi Chocolate and Gelato
7. Surreal Creamery

Number of companies

10532

Verified reviews

4,63

Average rating

(646)3743987

1. Venchi Chocolate & Gelato

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

1796 Broadway, 10019.0, New York

Ice cream shop
Chocolate shop

Why we chose them

Venchi Chocolate & Gelato Columbus Circle is a premier destination for connoisseurs of fine Italian chocolate and gelato. Known for its rich heritage dating back to 1878, the company offers a delightful array of artisanal chocolates and creamy gelato, crafted with authentic Italian know-how and creativity. Customers are treated to an indulgent experience with unique flavors and textures, making it a must-visit spot for anyone with a sweet tooth. Their offerings include everything from classic chocolate bars to innovative creations like their iconic Chocoviar, ensuring a sophisticated mix of contrasts and surprising fillings.

Beyond the delectable products, the shop engages its community with enticing promotions such as the “Buy 3 Bars, Get 1 Dark Gianduia Bar for FREE” and offers like free standard shipping on orders over $90. The V-Club loyalty program further enhances the customer experience by providing discounts on every purchase. Additionally, Venchi emphasizes sustainability and the use of plant-based ingredients, catering to evolving tastes and dietary needs. With its commitment to quality and innovation, this chocolate and gelato haven stands out as a cherished part of the community.

(212)2097684

2. Morgenstern's Bananas

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,2/5

2 Rivington St, 10002.0, New York

Ice cream shop
Cafe

Why we chose them

Morgenstern’s BANANAS stands out in the world of frozen treats with its inventive approach to soft serve. Renowned for its creative flavors and toppings, this parlor offers a delightful twist on traditional ice cream. With options like Banana, Coffee Creamer, and Midnight Choc, customers can explore unique taste experiences. The parlor also serves as a cafe, enhancing the variety of offerings available to patrons. This innovative approach to flavor and presentation makes it a must-visit for dessert enthusiasts.

Known for its playful and inviting atmosphere, Morgenstern’s BANANAS brings a fresh perspective to the soft serve scene. The menu is a testament to their creativity, featuring flavors such as Salted Peanut Butter and Orange Caramel Popcorn. Moreover, they provide opportunities to bring these delightful treats to events, adding a special touch to any gathering. With a focus on non-dairy options and an engaging assortment of merchandise and gift cards, this parlor offers something for everyone, ensuring a memorable visit.

(646)8611957

3. Anita La Mamma del Gelato

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

1561 2nd Ave, 10028.0, New York

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Anita La Mamma del Gelato is a renowned ice cream shop celebrated for its exquisite gelato, crafted with a fusion of iconic New York spirit and timeless craftsmanship. With humble beginnings in a small kitchen over 22 years ago, the brand has grown into a global sensation, offering a delightful array of flavors that captivate taste buds worldwide. Each scoop is a testament to their commitment to quality, using only the finest ingredients to ensure every bite is a memorable experience. Their bestsellers include luxurious chocolate, vegan cookie & cream, and pistachio cream, showcasing a diverse range of choices for every palate.

The company’s story is rooted in a rich heritage, with Mama Anita and her son Nir creating unique frozen treats that quickly became favorites among friends and neighbors. Today, their gelato shops are found across the globe, inviting dessert enthusiasts to indulge in their world-famous flavors. The brand’s dedication to innovation and quality is evident in their seasonal offerings and engaging blog content, which explores everything from the differences between gelato and ice cream to the secrets behind vegan ice cream. This commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction is why the company stands out in our directory.

(212)2266758

4. FIGO il Gelato Italiano

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,8/5

178 Mulberry St, 10012.0, New York

Ice cream shop
Dessert shop

Why we chose them

FIGO il Gelato Italiano is a renowned artisanal gelateria located in the heart of NYC, offering a taste of authentic Italian gelato. The expertise and recipes originate from Bologna, Italy, ensuring every scoop is a genuine Italian experience. This dessert shop prides itself on using locally-sourced fruits, farm-fresh hormone-free milk, and natural ingredients to create a low-fat, healthy, and delicious treat. Each batch of gelato is handcrafted daily, preserving its rich flavor and silky texture while maintaining an environmentally friendly approach by preparing just enough for daily consumption.

With a diverse menu that includes classic gelato flavors like Stracciatella, Pistachio, and Ferrero Rocher, as well as unique creations such as Figo (Ricotta, caramelized figs, amaretti), this ice cream shop offers a delightful array of options. In addition to gelato, customers can indulge in pastries, Italian espresso, and other hot drinks, making it a perfect spot for a sweet break. The passionate team behind this venture brings decades of experience from the former Mo Gelato, ensuring a top-tier and authentic Italian dessert experience. Their commitment to tradition, quality, and innovation is what sets them apart, creating a memorable moment with every bite.

5. Ray's Candy Store

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

113 Avenue A, 10009.0, New York

Ice cream shop
Candy store
Coffee shop
Confectionery store
Deli
Fast food restaurant
Frozen yogurt shop
Hot dog restaurant
Dessert shop

Why we chose them

Ray’s Candy Store is a beloved, quirky 24-hour hub in New York City, known for serving up the city’s best fries, shakes, ice cream, and much more since 1974. This iconic establishment, celebrated as an NYC institution, offers a delightful array of treats including hot dogs, egg creams, and deep-fried Oreos. Open late every day, it has become a staple of the East Village, earning the title of Best Restaurant in the area at the inaugural Time Out New York Love New York Awards. The store’s commitment to quality is evident in its motto, “Everything Made With Love™,” and even culinary legend Anthony Bourdain praised its superb egg cream.

With a wide range of services, including those of an ice cream shop, candy store, coffee shop, confectionery store, deli, and fast food restaurant, this establishment ensures there’s something for everyone. Customers can enjoy their favorites on-site or opt for delivery through Uber Eats, Seamless, GrubHub, Postmates, Caviar, and DoorDash. Celebrating 50 years in business, Ray’s Candy Store remains a cherished part of the community, frequently highlighted in media outlets like Humans of New York and The Bowery Boys Podcast. Its vibrant presence on social media platforms like Instagram and Facebook keeps its loyal customer base engaged and informed.

(646)5881043

6. Venchi Chocolate and Gelato

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,9/5

198 Columbus Ave, 10023.0, New York

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Venchi Chocolate and Gelato Columbus Av. stands out as a premium destination for ice cream enthusiasts, offering a rich selection of gelato flavors crafted with authentic Italian expertise. Known for its legacy since 1878, Venchi blends tradition with contemporary tastes, ensuring a delightful experience for every visitor. The shop’s commitment to quality is evident in their use of fine ingredients, which create a unique and sophisticated mix of flavors and textures. Their offerings extend beyond gelato to include a range of fine Italian chocolates, making it a paradise for chocolate lovers.

Visitors to the shop can take advantage of enticing promotions, such as buying three chocolate bars to receive a complimentary Dark Gianduia Bar, or enjoying free standard shipping on orders over $90. Customers are also encouraged to join the V-Club to unlock discounts on every purchase, making it a rewarding stop for both locals and tourists. With a focus on sustainability and innovation, Venchi continues to meet evolving tastes with plant-based options and limited-edition offerings, like their pistachio spread. This dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is why this establishment is featured in our directory.

(646)4550093

7. Surreal Creamery

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

538 2nd Ave, 10016.0, New York

Ice cream shop
Bubble tea store
Cake shop
Cupcake shop
Dessert shop
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Surreal Creamery captivates with its vibrant and cozy ambiance, offering a delightful escape for those seeking offbeat sweet treats. Known for its innovative and playful approach to desserts, this unique establishment has earned a spot in our directory for its creative flair and commitment to quality. The cafe seamlessly blends the worlds of an ice cream shop, bubble tea store, and dessert shop, creating an irresistible haven for dessert enthusiasts.

In addition to its signature offerings, the company also serves as a cake shop and cupcake shop, making it a versatile destination for various sweet cravings. The diverse array of indulgent options ensures a memorable experience for every visitor, whether they’re in the mood for a refreshing bubble tea or a decadent dessert. This winning combination of creativity and variety is what sets the cafe apart and makes it a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists alike.

FAQs

What types of ice cream flavors can I expect to find in New York's ice cream shops?

New York's ice cream shops offer a diverse range of flavors, from classic options like vanilla and chocolate to exotic seasonal specials and unique creations. You can also find innovative combinations and limited edition flavors.

Are there vegan and dairy-free ice cream options available in New York?

Yes, many ice cream shops in New York offer vegan and dairy-free options to cater to different dietary preferences and restrictions. These alternatives often use plant-based ingredients to provide a delicious experience for everyone.

What is the average price range for ice cream in New York?

The average price for ice cream in New York typically ranges from €2.50 to €9 per serving, depending on the size, flavors, and toppings chosen. Prices can vary based on location and shop.

What are some popular toppings and customizations available at New York ice cream shops?

Popular toppings include caramel drizzle, fresh fruits, nuts, chocolate chips, and gourmet sprinkles. Many shops also offer customizable sundae options, allowing you to build your own dessert with your preferred toppings.

How can I choose the best ice cream shop in New York for my taste preferences?

Consider factors such as the variety of flavors, availability of homemade options, dietary alternatives, shop ambiance, and location. Reading reviews and asking for recommendations can also help you find the perfect spot.

What should I consider when selecting an ice cream shop based on ambiance?

Think about the atmosphere you prefer, whether it's quirky, cozy, or modern. The shop's decor and vibe can enhance your overall experience, making it more enjoyable and memorable.

Are there any ice cream shops in New York that offer homemade ice cream?

Yes, many shops in New York pride themselves on offering homemade ice creams. These are often made on-site with fresh ingredients, providing a unique taste profile and ensuring high quality.

How important is the location of an ice cream shop in New York?

Location can be important if you want easy access or proximity to other attractions. Choosing a shop near popular areas might enhance your experience, especially if you're exploring the city.