Top 7 Best Caterers in New York

New York City is renowned for its diverse culinary scene, and when it comes to finding the perfect caterer for your event, the options are as varied as the city itself. Whether you’re planning a lavish wedding, a corporate gathering, or an intimate dinner party, choosing the right catering service is crucial to ensuring a memorable experience. Our guide to the ‘Top 7 Best Caterers in New York’ will help you navigate the multitude of options and find the perfect fit for your needs.

Before diving into the list, consider the following services and aspects that top-notch caterers in New York might offer:

Menu Customization: Tailor-made menus to suit dietary preferences and event themes.
Event Planning: Comprehensive planning services to ensure every detail is covered.
Staffing Services: Professional chefs, servers, and bartenders to enhance the event experience.
Venue Coordination: Assistance with selecting and coordinating the perfect venue.
Decor and Presentation: Artistic food presentation and decor to match the event’s style.
Budget Management: Options to fit various budgets, with transparent pricing typically ranging from $25 to $200 per person.

Explore our curated list of the top 7 caterers who excel in delivering exceptional culinary experiences and impeccable service, making your event truly unforgettable.

1. Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish
2. Strokos Gourmet Deli
3. Potbelly Sandwich Shop

4. Montagu's Gusto
5. Potbelly
6. Evelyn's Kitchen
7. L&M Delicatessen and Catering

Number of companies

2620

Verified reviews

4,21

Average rating

(212)8742800

1. Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 3,9/5

273 Columbus Ave, 10023.0, New York

Bagel shop
Caterer
Deli
Delivery Restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Restaurant
Sandwich shop

Why we chose them

Zucker’s Bagels & Smoked Fish is renowned for its dedication to crafting authentic, hand-rolled bagels paired with an array of delectable spreads. This beloved establishment has carved out a niche in the culinary scene by offering a unique blend of traditional and contemporary flavors. As a versatile bagel shop, it attracts patrons with its quality offerings and artisanal approach to bagel-making, making it a standout choice for those seeking genuine taste experiences.

Beyond its reputation as a bagel shop, Zucker’s serves as a comprehensive caterer, deli, and sandwich shop, providing a wide array of options for every palate. Customers can enjoy the convenience of a delivery restaurant and takeout restaurant, ensuring that their favorite flavors are accessible anywhere. Its commitment to quality and service makes it a perfect addition to our directory, highlighting its role as a versatile culinary destination.

(212)6662121

2. Strokos Gourmet Deli

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,0/5

1090 Amsterdam Ave, 10025.0, New York

Caterer
Deli
Pizza restaurant

Why we chose them

Known for its welcoming atmosphere and delightful aromas, Strokos Gourmet Deli is a popular destination for those seeking a quick and satisfying meal. As a versatile deli, it offers a diverse menu that includes sandwiches, salads, and pizza, all served in a clean and comfortable setting. The inviting interior design adds to the overall experience, making customers feel right at home from the moment they walk in. Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast to enjoy their famed omelets or a bowl of hot oatmeal, the quality and freshness of their offerings are consistently praised.

In addition to its delicious individual offerings, the deli also excels as a caterer, providing a convenient option for events and gatherings. The enticing aroma from their pizza ovens is just one of the many sensory delights that keep patrons returning time and again. With its commitment to maintaining a pleasant environment and offering a variety of tempting dishes, the deli stands out as a top choice for anyone seeking a dependable pizza restaurant experience. This combination of quality service and flavorful food makes it a worthy addition to our company directory.

(646)2894211

3. Potbelly Sandwich Shop

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,1/5

90 Broad St, 10004.0, New York

Caterer
Beverage distributor
Sandwich shop
Deli
Lunch restaurant
Restaurant supply store

Why we chose them

Potbelly Sandwich Shop stands out as a beloved casual chain renowned for its delicious toasted sandwiches. Known for its inviting and relaxed atmosphere, this eatery has become a favorite spot for sandwich lovers seeking quality and flavor. The shop crafts each sandwich with care, ensuring a satisfying experience for every customer. It’s a perfect place for a quick lunch or a casual meal with friends, offering a variety of options that cater to diverse tastes.

In addition to its reputation as a sandwich shop, the company offers an array of services that make it a versatile choice for many needs. As a caterer, it provides convenient and delectable options for events, while its role as a beverage distributor complements its food offerings. Furthermore, it functions as a deli, lunch restaurant, and restaurant supply store, showcasing its commitment to serving both individual customers and businesses. This multifaceted approach makes it a distinguished name in the food industry.

(917)2614129

4. Montagu's Gusto

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

645 2nd Ave, 10016.0, New York

Caterer
Catering food and drink supplier
Sandwich shop
Coffee shop
Delivery Restaurant
Salad shop

Why we chose them

Montagu’s Gusto is a cozy artisan eatery nestled in the heart of Murray Hill, New York. Known for its upscale deli cafe experience, it offers a delightful blend of globally inspired flavors made from locally sourced, fresh ingredients. Patrons can enjoy a wide array of services including catering, sandwich and salad shops, a coffee shop, and a delivery restaurant. The menu is thoughtfully crafted to provide a unique dining experience with signature choices available for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, all made to order to ensure the freshest taste.

This vibrant eatery stands out for its commitment to sustainable practices and organic specialties. It’s a go-to spot for both residents and professionals in the area, particularly those near NYU Langone and NYU Medical Center. With its mouth-watering offerings and emphasis on quality, Montagu’s Gusto is a favorite for those seeking a fusion of healthy and delicious options in a warm and inviting atmosphere. The establishment’s dedication to excellence makes it a noteworthy addition to our company directory, embodying the essence of fresh and flavorful dining.

(646)3074896

5. Potbelly

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,1/5

127 Fulton St, 10038.0, New York

Sandwich shop
Caterer
Deli

Why we chose them

Potbelly, a beloved casual chain, specializes in crafting delicious toasted sandwiches that have earned a loyal following. Known for its inviting atmosphere, this sandwich shop offers a unique blend of flavors, creating a delightful dining experience for its customers. The company stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and its dedication to delivering mouthwatering sandwiches that satisfy a variety of tastes.

Beyond being just a sandwich shop, Potbelly also excels as a caterer and deli, providing convenient and tasty options for events and gatherings. Its catering services are perfect for both small and large occasions, ensuring that guests enjoy the same delicious flavors that have made the chain popular. By combining exceptional service with a diverse menu, the company effectively meets the needs of its diverse clientele.

(646)4767906

6. Evelyn's Kitchen

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

storefront, 2317 1st Ave., 10035.0, New York

Caterer
Bakery
American restaurant
Gift shop
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Evelyn’s Kitchen, nestled in East Harlem, is celebrated for its commitment to “Honest Food. Done Exceptionally Well.” This bakeshop and café offers a unique blend of upscale comfort food, prepared fresh to order, and has been recognized by New York Magazine as a top choice in the city. With a focus on innovative menus and indulgent goodies, this family-owned, woman-led business has been delighting foodies since 2009. Their signature ‘Pudgies’ have gained fame on platforms such as Food Network and Oprah’s ‘O’ Magazine, showcasing their delectable creations to a national audience.

The company excels as a caterer, providing exceptional corporate and production catering services, trusted by renowned clients like Viacom and Moet Hennessy. Beyond catering, it operates as a bakery, American restaurant, and gift shop, making it a hidden gem for those seeking diverse culinary experiences. Evelyn’s Kitchen’s dedication to exceptional customer service and flawless presentation has established it as a beloved destination. Their influence in the culinary world is further solidified by a decade-long presence in the community and features on shows like Good Morning America. Visitors are invited to experience firsthand the heart, personality, and integrity that define this remarkable establishment.

(212)2422645

7. L&M Delicatessen and Catering

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

Cross streets are 15th & 16th, 80 7th Ave, 10011.0, New York

Caterer
Beer store
Breakfast restaurant
Coffee shop
Deli
Grocery delivery service
Ice cream shop
Salad shop
Sandwich shop
Soup shop

Why we chose them

L&M Delicatessen and Catering stands out in the bustling culinary scene with its ability to craft customized sandwiches and salads tailored to individual tastes. Known for its diverse offerings, this deli is a go-to destination for anyone craving a unique culinary experience. The company excels as a caterer, providing top-notch service for various events, and also operates as a beer store, offering an impressive selection of beverages to complement any meal. Patrons can enjoy a delightful breakfast at the breakfast restaurant, or savor a well-brewed cup at the coffee shop.

Beyond its deli roots, the establishment serves as a convenient grocery delivery service, bringing essentials right to your doorstep. Sweet tooths will appreciate the ice cream shop, while health-conscious customers can indulge at the salad shop. Sandwich aficionados will find plenty to love at the sandwich shop, and those seeking comfort food can choose from a variety of options at the soup shop. The diverse range of services offered makes this company a versatile choice for food lovers and event planners alike, earning it a well-deserved spot in our directory.

FAQs

What services do top caterers in New York typically offer?

Top caterers in New York often provide menu customization, event planning, staffing services, venue coordination, decor and presentation, and budget management.

How much does catering typically cost in New York?

Catering services in New York generally range from €23 to €185 per person, depending on the menu, venue, and level of service required.

How far in advance should I book a caterer for my event?

It's advisable to book a caterer at least 6 to 12 months in advance for large events like weddings, and 3 to 6 months for smaller gatherings.

What should I consider when choosing a caterer in New York?

Consider factors such as menu options, experience, reviews, budget, and whether they offer additional services like event planning and staffing.

Can caterers accommodate dietary restrictions and preferences?

Yes, many caterers offer menu customization to accommodate dietary restrictions such as vegan, gluten-free, or kosher options.

Do caterers in New York provide event planning services?

Many top caterers offer comprehensive event planning services to ensure all details are managed, from logistics to decor.

Are there budget-friendly catering options available in New York?

Yes, many caterers offer budget management services and transparent pricing to fit various budget ranges, ensuring quality service at different price points.

How can I ensure the quality of a caterer's service?

Check online reviews, ask for references, and attend tastings to evaluate the quality of food and service before making a decision.