The 7 Best Cake Shops in New York

New York City is a hub of culinary delights, and when it comes to indulging your sweet tooth, the city’s cake shops are in a league of their own. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, exploring the finest cake shops in NYC is a must. Our guide to the 7 Best Cake Shops in New York will take you on a journey through the most delectable and visually stunning cakes the city has to offer. From classic flavors to innovative creations, these shops cater to every craving and occasion.

When choosing a cake shop, consider the following services and aspects:

Custom Cake Design – Personalized cakes for birthdays, weddings, and special events.
Flavor Variety – A wide range of flavors from classic vanilla and chocolate to unique combinations.
Vegan and Gluten-Free Options – Delicious alternatives for those with dietary restrictions.
Online Ordering – Convenient options for browsing and purchasing cakes from the comfort of your home.
Delivery Services – Ensure your cake arrives fresh and on time for your celebration.
Pricing – Cakes can range from $20 for a simple design to over $100 for elaborate creations.
Reputation and Reviews – Consider customer feedback and ratings to ensure quality and satisfaction.

Embark on a sweet adventure with us as we explore the top cake destinations in the city that never sleeps, and discover where to find the perfect slice for your next celebration.

1. Tous Les Jours
2. Molly's Cupcakes
3. Mille-feuille Bakery Cafe

4. Keki Modern Cakes
5. La Bergamote
6. Chikalicious Dessert Bar
7. Ole & Steen

Number of companies

7495

Verified reviews

4,49

Average rating

(212)9679661

1. Tous Les Jours

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

31 W 32nd St, 10001.0, New York

Patisserie

Why we chose them

Tous Les Jours stands out as a unique fusion of French and Asian bakery traditions, offering an enticing array of freshly baked goods every day. Known for its commitment to quality, the company prides itself on using only the finest ingredients to craft breads, cakes, pastries, and pies that delight the senses. Each creation is a testament to the skilled craftsmanship of their bakers, who infuse every product with exceptional taste and wholesome qualities, perfect for any occasion.

Beyond its delectable bakery offerings, the company provides an impressive selection of beverages, including bold espresso, teas, and handcrafted smoothies. These drinks serve as the perfect accompaniment to their artisan baked goods. With locations across several states, including California, New York, and Texas, customers can easily find a store nearby for a memorable bakery experience. Recognized for its growth and innovation, the company has earned a spot on the Franchise Times’ prestigious Top 500 Franchises List and is poised for further expansion in the U.S. market.

(212)4142253

2. Molly's Cupcakes

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

228 Bleecker St, 10014.0, New York

Cupcake shop
Bakery

Why we chose them

Molly’s Cupcakes stands out in our directory for its vibrant and creative approach to baking. Known for its bright and inviting atmosphere, this bakery specializes in offering a delightful array of cupcakes and treats. With a heartfelt origin story rooted in the founder’s childhood memories of his third-grade teacher, Molly, the bakery embraces a nostalgic and community-focused ethos. Celebrated for its signature flavors like Cake Batter, Creme Brulee, and Blueberry Cheesecake, the bakery provides a unique twist on classic desserts. Their dedication to supporting local schools further underscores their commitment to community engagement, making each visit not just a treat but a meaningful experience.

Offering services that include a cupcake shop and bakery, this establishment has expanded its presence across various locations, including Chicago, New York, Iowa, Ohio, Nashville, and Ann Arbor. The menu is crafted to cater to diverse tastes, featuring inventive flavors like Cookie Monster and Samoa, ensuring there is something for everyone. Beyond individual indulgences, they also cater to weddings and events, providing bespoke baked goods for special occasions. Recognized for their quality and creativity, this bakery has become a beloved spot for those seeking both delicious treats and a touch of warmth from cherished memories.

3. Mille-feuille Bakery Cafe

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

2175 Broadway, 10023.0, New York

Patisserie
Cafe

Why we chose them

Mille-feuille Bakery Cafe stands out in our directory for its dedication to crafting authentic French pastries. Known for their classic sweets, this patisserie offers an exquisite selection of baked goods that capture the essence of traditional French baking. The cafe’s menu boasts a variety of delicacies, from buttery croissants to delicate macarons, each made with meticulous attention to detail and quality ingredients. Their commitment to preserving the rich heritage of French patisserie makes them a beloved spot for those seeking a taste of France.

Beyond its renowned baked offerings, this establishment also functions as a cozy cafe, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere for patrons to enjoy their treats. Whether you’re stopping by for a leisurely coffee or indulging in a sweet escape, the ambiance complements the culinary experience perfectly. The combination of a dedicated patisserie and a charming cafe setting is why this company is a noteworthy addition to our directory, appealing to both locals and visitors with its authentic flavors and welcoming environment.

(646)8632094

4. Keki Modern Cakes

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

79 Mott St, 10013.0, New York

Bakery
Cake shop

Why we chose them

Keki Modern Cakes is renowned for its delightful Japanese cheesecakes, offering a unique and delicious experience in the world of baked goods. Known as the home of the USA’s first bouncy cheesecake, this bakery specializes in crafting jiggly castella and fancy cheesecakes. The company prides itself on its commitment to responsible sourcing, utilizing cage-free eggs and grass-fed organic milk from trusted farms in Upstate New York and Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Each cake is freshly made every 20 minutes, ensuring the highest quality and freshness in every bite.

This bakery and cake shop stands out for its dedication to pure ingredients and collaboration with local partners to provide light, fluffy, and healthy treats. Every dessert is made from scratch in-house at its midtown and downtown locations, capturing the essence of purity and goodness. Their belief in using only the freshest ingredients underscores their mission to deliver exceptional cakes that are as delightful to the palate as they are to the conscience. Follow their journey and creations on Instagram at @kekimoderncakes for a glimpse into their world of sweet indulgence.

(212)6279010

5. La Bergamote

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

177 9th Ave, 10011.0, New York

Patisserie
Bakery
French restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

La Bergamote, nestled in the heart of Chelsea, NYC, is a beloved purveyor of authentic French cuisine. Established in May 1998 by owners Romain Lamaze and Stephane Willemin, this French bakery and café has become a staple in the community. Known for its fresh, quality interpretations of classic French dishes, it also delights patrons with daily baked pastries. The dedication to consistent product quality and the use of fresh ingredients have cemented its reputation as a go-to destination for French culinary delights.

Offering a variety of services, including Patisserie, Bakery, and French restaurant experiences, La Bergamote seamlessly blends traditional and contemporary French flavors. Whether you’re stopping by for a fresh pastry or indulging in a full meal, the commitment to excellence is evident in every bite. This dedication to quality and authenticity is why it proudly holds a place in our company directory as a standout example of fine French dining in New York City.

(212)9959511

6. Chikalicious Dessert Bar

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

203 E 10th St, 10003.0, New York

Cake shop
Sandwich shop

Why we chose them

ChikaLicious Dessert Bar in the East Village of NYC offers an upscale and intimate experience with its innovative creations. Known for introducing the Tahitian Vanilla Burnt Basque Mille Crêpe, this dessert haven has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. The chef’s bold exploration of flavors brings a unique twist to traditional treats, making it a must-visit destination for dessert enthusiasts. Their offerings extend beyond sweets, with an intriguing blend of culinary artistry that includes a distinctive take on Japanese cured eggs, transforming simple ingredients into a global sensation.

The menu is a testament to creativity and passion, featuring a harmonious blend of flavors such as the Japanese cured runny egg, thyme biscuit, and lox of gaspe nova, which collectively deliver a delightful umami explosion. This culinary innovation has positioned the establishment as a pioneering force in the dessert and culinary scene. With services that include both a cake shop and a sandwich shop, the company continues to captivate guests with its imaginative offerings, making it a standout choice for our directory.

(929)2091540

7. Ole & Steen

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

80 W 40th St, 10018.0, New York

Bakery
Breakfast restaurant
Brunch restaurant
Cafe
Cake shop
Coffee shop
Coffee store
Lunch restaurant
Pastry shop
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Ole & Steen is a vibrant all-day Danish bakery and restaurant located in the heart of New York City, known for its eclectic range of offerings. The establishment seamlessly combines the charm of a traditional bakery with the modern flair of a cafe and restaurant. From breakfast to brunch, lunch, and everything in between, Ole & Steen provides a warm and inviting atmosphere for patrons to enjoy fresh pastries, artisanal cakes, and expertly brewed coffee. The bakery is a go-to destination for those seeking high-quality Danish delicacies and a delightful culinary experience.

With multiple locations across NYC, such as Midtown East, Union Square, Bryant Park, Tribeca, and the Upper East Side, Ole & Steen is easily accessible for both locals and tourists. Their comprehensive menu, available to order online, features seasonal specialties like Halloween treats and celebration cakes, ensuring there’s always something new to try. Additionally, the company offers catering services, making it a perfect choice for gatherings and events. Ole & Steen’s commitment to quality and craft makes it a standout choice in our directory, offering a unique blend of traditional Danish baking and contemporary dining.

FAQs

What services do cake shops in New York typically offer?

Cake shops in New York generally offer custom cake design for special events, a wide range of flavors, vegan and gluten-free options, online ordering, and delivery services.

How much do custom cakes usually cost in New York?

Custom cakes in New York can range from €18 to €90, depending on the complexity and size of the design.

How far in advance should I order a custom cake?

It's recommended to order a custom cake at least 1-2 weeks in advance to ensure availability and allow time for design and preparation.

What should I consider when choosing a cake shop?

Consider factors such as the shop's reputation, customer reviews, flavor variety, dietary options, pricing, and delivery services.

Are there vegan and gluten-free cake options available in New York?

Yes, many cake shops in New York offer delicious vegan and gluten-free options to accommodate dietary restrictions.

Can I order cakes online from New York cake shops?

Most cake shops in New York offer convenient online ordering options, allowing you to browse and purchase cakes from home.

Do cake shops in New York offer delivery services?

Yes, many cake shops provide delivery services to ensure your cake arrives fresh and on time for your celebration.