The 7 Best Steakhouses in New York

New York City is a culinary haven, renowned for its diverse food scene, and when it comes to the art of grilling, the city boasts some of the finest steakhouses in the world. Our guide, “The 7 Best Steakhouses in New York,” will take you on a savory journey through the city’s top destinations for succulent steaks, mouthwatering sides, and an unforgettable dining experience.

Whether you’re a local or a visitor, choosing the perfect steakhouse can be daunting with so many exceptional options. Here are some key services and aspects to consider when selecting a steakhouse in New York:

Menu Variety: Look for diverse cuts of beef, from ribeye to filet mignon, and consider options for non-beef eaters.
Quality of Meat: Consider whether the steakhouse offers USDA Prime, dry-aged, or grass-fed beef.
Wine and Cocktail Selection: A curated list of wines and creative cocktails can enhance your dining experience.
Ambiance: From classic elegance to modern chic, the atmosphere can set the tone for your meal.
Service: Attentive and knowledgeable staff can elevate your dining experience.
Price Range: Be prepared for a range of prices, from $50 to $150 per person, depending on your choices.
Location: Proximity and accessibility can be key factors in your decision-making.
Private Dining: Consider options for private rooms or special events.

Explore the post to discover the 7 best spots to indulge in perfectly cooked steaks, each offering something unique to satisfy every palate. Bon appétit!

1. Gallaghers Steakhouse
2. Quality Meats
3. Benjamin Steakhouse

4. Sparks Steak House
5. Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
6. Charlie Palmer Steak IV
7. West Side Steakhouse

Number of companies

19613

Verified reviews

4,53

Average rating

(212)5865000

1. Gallaghers Steakhouse

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

228 W 52nd St, 10019.0, New York

Steak house
Bar

Why we chose them

Gallaghers Steakhouse stands as a venerable institution in New York City, with a rich history dating back to its founding in 1927. Originally opened as a speakeasy by Helen Gallagher, a former Ziegfeld dancer, and the charismatic sports enthusiast Jack Solomon, the establishment quickly became a haven for gamblers, sports figures, and Broadway stars. Located near the vibrant energy of Times Square, it has been the backdrop for significant moments in the city’s history, from sports victories to celebrity celebrations. Over the decades, Gallaghers has maintained its status by offering an authentic New York steakhouse experience, renowned for its USDA prime dry-aged beef, cooked to perfection over signature hickory coals, and served with world-class cocktails.

The dining experience at Gallaghers Steakhouse is steeped in tradition, with its legendary windowed meat locker showcasing cuts that are dry-aged for 21 days to enhance flavor. The steakhouse invites guests to enjoy a variety of steaks such as Filet Mignon, Strip Steak, Ribeye, Porterhouse, and the iconic Tomahawk. While guests are welcomed in a range of attire, the restaurant maintains a respectful dress code, refraining from hats, shorts, and sports jerseys. Additionally, in compliance with New York law, proof of vaccination is required for entry. This blend of history, culinary excellence, and tradition makes it an essential addition to our company directory.

(212)3717777

2. Quality Meats

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

57 W 58th St, 10019.0, New York

American restaurant
Steak house

Why we chose them

Quality Meats stands out as a premier steakhouse in New York City, effortlessly blending the rustic charm of a butcher shop with modern sophistication. Known for its innovative presentations and distinctive style, this American restaurant offers a unique dining experience with both indoor and outdoor seating in chic, covered cabins. The menu features modern interpretations of classic dishes, resulting in unique flavor combinations that elevate the traditional steakhouse experience. This approach has earned it recognition from notable publications, showcasing its commitment to delivering exceptional taste and quality.

Located in Midtown, the steakhouse provides a versatile dining experience that includes dinner, lunch, cocktails, and a selection of desserts and wines. Quality Meats also caters to private events, offering a stylish venue for various occasions. Its reputation as one of the swankiest steakhouses in NYC is well-deserved, as it consistently delivers on its promise to transform the local butcher shop concept into a fine dining adventure. With a focus on quality and creativity, this establishment has become a must-visit destination for steak lovers seeking an unparalleled culinary journey.

(212)2979177

3. Benjamin Steakhouse

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

52 E 41st St, 10017.0, New York

Steak house
American restaurant

Why we chose them

Benjamin Steakhouse is renowned for its exquisite dry-aged beef and enticing bar bites, offering a quintessential American steakhouse experience. Known for its expert preparation and flavorful cuts, this establishment caters to those seeking a premium dining experience in a classic steakhouse setting. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and tradition makes it a standout choice for steak enthusiasts and those craving authentic American cuisine.

As a premium steak house and American restaurant, it has carved a niche for itself by delivering unparalleled flavors and an inviting atmosphere. The focus on expertly aged beef highlights its dedication to culinary excellence, drawing patrons who appreciate both taste and tradition. This dedication to quality and service is why this establishment is featured in our directory.

(212)6874855

4. Sparks Steak House

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

210 E 46th St, 10017.0, New York

Steak house
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Sparks Steak House, established in 1966, is a storied dining spot renowned for its choice cuts and exquisite wines. As a family-owned business, it prides itself on delivering a top-tier steakhouse experience in the heart of New York City. The commitment to quality and continuous improvement is evident in every aspect of the restaurant, from the meticulously crafted a la carte menu to the selection of fine wines and desserts. Guests can enjoy an elegant dining atmosphere, enhanced by private room options for special events, making it a perfect choice for both intimate dinners and grand celebrations.

The restaurant’s legacy of excellence is reflected in its recognition as the #1 rated steakhouse in NYC. Patrons are invited to savor a culinary journey that pairs the finest cuts of steak with a wide array of beverages. Sparks Steak House also offers convenient options for online reservations and ordering, ensuring a seamless experience for all guests. With its rich history and dedication to customer satisfaction, this establishment continues to be a cornerstone of New York City’s vibrant dining scene.

(212)3380818

5. Benjamin Steakhouse Prime

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

Between Park and, 23 E 40th St, Madison Ave, 10016.0, New York

Steak house
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is renowned for its exquisite culinary offerings, specializing in dry-aged beef that promises a rich and flavorful dining experience. The modern steakhouse ambiance is complemented by a diverse menu that includes both raw and grilled seafood, offering a unique blend of flavors for every palate. Known for its expert preparation and quality ingredients, the steakhouse provides a casual yet sophisticated setting, making it an ideal choice for both steak enthusiasts and seafood lovers alike.

Beyond its signature dry-aged steaks, the establishment features a casual bar menu, allowing guests to enjoy a variety of bar bites in a relaxed atmosphere. This combination of high-quality steak and diverse menu options is what makes the restaurant a standout choice, offering a unique dining experience in a contemporary setting. The attention to detail in both service and culinary execution is what sets this steakhouse apart, ensuring a memorable visit for all who walk through its doors.

(212)3191660

6. Charlie Palmer Steak IV

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

The Knickerbocker Hotel, 6 Times Sq 4th floor, 10036.0, New York

Steak house

Why we chose them

Charlie Palmer Steak IV stands as a modern beacon of culinary excellence in the heart of New York City. Situated on the fourth floor of The Knickerbocker Hotel, this expansive American steakhouse encapsulates the elegance and legacy of its iconic surroundings. The venue’s sophisticated design and immersive tableside service provide a contemporary twist on the traditional steakhouse experience, offering guests a unique and exquisite dining atmosphere. With a menu crafted to highlight specialty offerings, it seamlessly blends opulence with a welcoming vibe, staying true to the renowned Charlie Palmer Steak philosophy.

Celebrated Chef Charlie Palmer, along with Executive Chef Adam Raksin, leads the culinary team in creating an exceptional fine dining experience that evolves with the ever-changing world of gastronomy. The steakhouse is not just a place to dine but an experience in itself, echoing the luxury and refinement of The Knickerbocker Hotel. Known for its innovative approach, Charlie Palmer Steak IV offers services like pre-theatre dining and private dining events, making it an ideal choice for both intimate gatherings and special occasions. The restaurant is a testament to Chef Palmer’s commitment to delivering unparalleled dining experiences in a legendary setting.

(212)5644803

7. West Side Steakhouse

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

597 10th Ave, 10036.0, New York

Steak house
American restaurant

Why we chose them

West Side Steakhouse stands out as an inviting destination for those seeking a blend of classic and contemporary dining in New York City. Known for its unpretentious charm, this steak and seafood restaurant offers a unique experience with a vibe that perfectly marries modern flair with traditional elements. Guests can indulge in a menu that celebrates the finest ingredients, featuring delectable dishes like Caesar salad, shrimp cocktail, crab cakes, and aged, Certified Angus premium steaks. This culinary haven provides an atmosphere that exudes both relaxation and sophistication, making it an ideal choice for any occasion, from a casual night out with friends to an intimate dinner.

Located in the vibrant Hell’s Kitchen area, just steps away from iconic New York landmarks like the Theatre District and Times Square, this American restaurant offers more than just exceptional food. Guests are welcomed into a space that embodies the “Old New York City” motif, creating a comfortable yet stylish ambiance. The perfect setting for every occasion, West Side Steakhouse ensures that each visit is memorable with impeccable service and attention to detail. Whether dining in or ordering online, patrons can expect a dining experience that combines old-world charm with modern luxury, all at prices that are accessible.