The 7 Best Italian Restaurants in New York

New York City is renowned for its diverse and vibrant dining scene, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, the city offers a plethora of options that cater to every palate. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty risotto, or a delicate tiramisu, our guide to the 7 Best Italian Restaurants in New York will lead you to the most authentic and delectable experiences.

Italian restaurants in New York are celebrated not only for their exceptional food but also for the unique atmosphere and services they provide. Here are some aspects to consider when choosing an Italian restaurant:

Authenticity of the recipes and ingredients
Ambiance that reflects the Italian culture
Availability of vegetarian and vegan options
Selection of Italian wines and other beverages
Pricing, with meals ranging from affordable options to luxury experiences
Quality of service and hospitality
Special features like live music or outdoor seating

Explore the best spots in the city to indulge in authentic Italian flavors and discover why these restaurants stand out among the rest.

1. Carmine's
2. New York Pizza Suprema
3. Ferrara Bakery & Cafe

4. Carmine's Italian Restaurant
5. Becco
6. Little Italy Pizza
7. Da Nico Ristorante

Number of companies

48556

Verified reviews

4,39

Average rating

(212)2213800

1. Carmine's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

200 W 44th St, 10036.0, New York

Italian restaurant
Caterer
Delivery service
Family restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Carmine’s is a family-friendly Italian restaurant renowned for its authentic Southern Italian cuisine, conveniently located near the heart of Times Square. Known for its hearty portions, each dish is designed to be shared, creating a communal dining experience that embodies the spirit of Italian family meals. This bustling eatery offers a variety of services, including catering and delivery, ensuring that guests can enjoy their favorite Italian meals at any venue. With private dining and banquet rooms available, Carmine’s is an ideal choice for hosting memorable gatherings, from intimate family dinners to large celebrations.

Accessibility is a key feature of Carmine’s, with its close proximity to major subway lines and bus routes, making it easily reachable from anywhere in the city. The restaurant also offers validated parking discounts, adding convenience for those who drive. As a bustling hub of activity, reservations are highly recommended to secure a spot in this popular dining destination. Whether opting for dine-in, take-out, or catering services, guests are guaranteed a delightful Italian culinary experience complemented by a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant’s strategic location near iconic New York attractions makes it a perfect stop for tourists and locals alike.

(212)5948939

2. New York Pizza Suprema

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

413 8th Ave, 10001.0, New York

Pizza restaurant
Italian restaurant

Why we chose them

NY Pizza Suprema has been serving classic slices and pies since 1964, making it a staple in New York’s vibrant pizza scene. Founded by Salvatore Riggio, this old-school pizzeria has maintained its charm and reputation for quality, even before the iconic Madison Square Garden was established nearby. Known for its authentic and straightforward approach to pizza, the restaurant has become a favorite stop on renowned tours like Scott’s Pizza Tours and Food On Foot Tours, attracting both locals and tourists looking for a taste of genuine New York street pizza.

Praised by culinary enthusiasts and celebrities alike, NY Pizza Suprema has been featured on popular shows such as Rachel Ray and The Today Show. With endorsements from notable figures like Curtis Stone and Lindsay Price, it’s clear that this pizzeria offers a slice worth going out of your way for. As an Italian restaurant, it continues to uphold its legacy, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking the quintessential New York pizza experience.

(212)2266150

3. Ferrara Bakery & Cafe

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

195 Grand St, 10013.0, New York

Italian restaurant
Bakery

Why we chose them

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe is an iconic destination renowned for its authentic Italian desserts, tracing its roots back to 1892 when it became America’s first pasticceria and espresso bar. Located in the heart of New York City’s Little Italy, this family-owned establishment has been delighting customers for five generations. Known for its commitment to quality, Ferrara continues to produce and ship some of the finest Italian pastries and confections in the country, maintaining its legacy and tradition from its original bakery on Grand Street.

Offering a unique blend of an Italian restaurant and bakery, Ferrara captivates visitors with its rich history and dedication to authenticity. The company’s enduring success is a testament to its ability to preserve traditional recipes while adapting to modern tastes. Chosen for our directory due to its historical significance and exceptional offerings, Ferrara remains a beloved establishment for both locals and tourists seeking a genuine taste of Italy in New York City.

(212)3622200

4. Carmine's Italian Restaurant

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

2450 Broadway, 10024.0, New York

Italian restaurant
Caterer
Delivery service
Event venue
Family restaurant
Takeout Restaurant

Why we chose them

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Upper West Side stands out as a celebrated family-friendly dining destination, offering a genuine taste of traditional Italian cuisine since 1990. Nestled in the vibrant Upper West Side of Manhattan, the restaurant is renowned for its generous portions designed for sharing, creating a warm and communal dining experience. The establishment caters to diverse needs with its array of services, including catering, delivery, takeout, and event hosting. Whether guests are visiting after exploring nearby attractions like Lincoln Center or Central Park, the restaurant promises a hearty Southern Italian meal that leaves a lasting impression.

At this flagship location, patrons can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere where large groups and locals mingle over classic Italian dishes. The venue is equipped with private dining and banquet rooms, making it an ideal choice for hosting special events and celebrations. With the convenience of online ordering and delivery, along with parking discounts and accessibility features, this establishment is committed to providing a seamless dining experience. Reservations are recommended due to its popularity, ensuring that everyone can savor the flavors of Italy in the heart of New York City.

(212)3977597

5. Becco

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

355 W 46th St, 10036.0, New York

Italian restaurant
Bar

Why we chose them

Becco stands out as a culinary gem located on New York’s renowned Restaurant Row in the vibrant theater district. Founded in 1993 by the esteemed Lidia Bastianich and her son, Joe, this Italian restaurant has been delighting patrons with its innovative cuisine and impeccable service for over two decades. The name, derived from the Italian verb “beccare,” embodies the restaurant’s philosophy of savoring each dish with discernment. Visitors are especially drawn to its acclaimed pasta tasting menu, which offers a delightful exploration of Italian flavors, and its extensive $31 wine list that pairs perfectly with the rich culinary offerings.

With its welcoming ambiance, Becco serves as an ideal destination for both intimate dining experiences and larger group gatherings. The restaurant’s versatile party packages are designed to accommodate any occasion, making it a popular choice for events of all sizes. Open seven days a week, Becco ensures that both locals and tourists can indulge in a memorable dining experience at any time. As a staple of New York’s dining scene, the restaurant continues to captivate guests with its dedication to quality and authenticity, making it a valued addition to our directory.

(212)4815200

6. Little Italy Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,2/5

2 E 33rd St, 10016.0, New York

Italian restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza Takeout
Restaurant
Sicilian restaurant
Southern Italian restaurant

Why we chose them

Little Italy Pizza brings a slice of authentic Italian tradition to New York with its New York-style pizzeria offerings. Known for its roots in family and tradition, the pizzeria captures the essence of “pizza alla casalinga,” reminiscent of the home-cooked pizzas from Southern Italy. The journey began with Salvatore, who learned the art of pizza-making under his grandma’s guidance. Today, the restaurant continues to honor this legacy by serving pizzas with a thin crust, topped with fresh tomatoes and generous cheese, perfected in modern ovens. The establishment offers a variety of services, including Italian, Sicilian, and Southern Italian dishes, catering to those seeking a genuine Italian dining experience.

With a commitment to bringing the flavors of Italy to New York, Little Italy Pizza provides a diverse range of services such as lunch, delivery, and takeout options, making it a convenient choice for pizza lovers. Customers can enjoy a seamless ordering experience online, whether opting for delivery or pickup. The pizzeria’s dedication to preserving its family heritage and delivering authentic tastes has made it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors. Emphasizing the homemade charm and quality ingredients, the restaurant invites everyone to indulge in a slice of Italy right in the heart of New York.

(212)3431212

7. Da Nico Ristorante

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

164 Mulberry St, 10013.0, New York

Italian restaurant
Bar
Dessert restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Da Nico Ristorante, a beloved red-sauce Italian establishment, has been a cherished part of the New York community since its founding in 1993. Family-owned and operated, it has become a staple in Little Italy, welcoming both locals and famous patrons such as the Yankees and former Mayor Giuliani. Known for its warm, homey atmosphere and attentive service, this restaurant offers a comprehensive dining experience with menus for lunch, dinner, and catering. Patrons can enjoy a diverse range of traditional Italian-American dishes, all prepared with quality ingredients that highlight the rich flavors of Italy.

Offering a variety of services as an Italian restaurant, bar, dessert restaurant, and pizza restaurant, Da Nico ensures every culinary craving is satisfied. Customers can order online or reserve a table to enjoy their meals in the cozy ambiance that the restaurant is known for. The rave reviews from satisfied diners speak to the exceptional service and delicious meals, including standout dishes like their famous carbonara. Da Nico’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction has cemented its reputation as a must-visit destination for Italian cuisine in New York City.

FAQs

What types of Italian cuisine can I expect at restaurants in New York?

Italian restaurants in New York offer a wide range of cuisines, including traditional dishes like pasta, pizza, and risotto, as well as regional specialties from areas like Tuscany, Sicily, and Naples.

What is the average price range for dining at an Italian restaurant in New York?

The average price for a meal at an Italian restaurant in New York ranges from €25 to €100 per person, depending on the restaurant's location, menu, and ambiance.

Do Italian restaurants in New York offer vegan or vegetarian options?

Yes, many Italian restaurants in New York offer vegan and vegetarian options, including dishes like vegetable-based pastas, pizzas with plant-based toppings, and fresh salads.

How can I choose a good Italian restaurant in New York?

To choose a good Italian restaurant, consider factors such as customer reviews, the authenticity of the menu, the atmosphere of the venue, and recommendations from locals or trusted food critics.

Are reservations required at Italian restaurants in New York?

While not always required, reservations are recommended, especially for popular or high-end Italian restaurants, to ensure you have a table at your desired time.

What should I consider when selecting an Italian restaurant for a special occasion in New York?

Consider the restaurant's ambiance, the quality of service, menu options, and whether they offer private dining areas or special packages for events.

Are there Italian restaurants in New York that offer delivery or takeout services?

Yes, many Italian restaurants in New York offer delivery and takeout services, allowing you to enjoy their cuisine at home. Check their websites or popular delivery apps for availability.

Do Italian restaurants in New York accommodate dietary restrictions?

Most Italian restaurants in New York are accommodating of dietary restrictions and offer options such as gluten-free pastas and dishes that can be modified to meet specific dietary needs.